Bulletproof your nest egg

The Quality vs. Quantity Retirement Myth (And Why It's Costing You Millions)

October 06, 20257 min read

Disclaimer: The calculations in this content are hypothetical, based on real client situations and specific mathematical assumptions. The assumptions are outlined in this document; for a full breakdown, contact [email protected].

Listen, I need to tell you something that might completely change how you think about retirement planning.

The quality of your retirement has more to do with the quality of your plan than the size of your bank account.

I know that sounds counterintuitive. We've been conditioned to believe that retirement success is all about accumulating as much money as possible. Bigger number equals better retirement, right?

Wrong.

While everyone's obsessing over portfolio size and chasing market returns, I just ran real numbers that prove intentional planning beats big balances every single time.

And the results will probably blow your mind.

So if you're here for the usual "save more and hope for the best" advice, you might want to scroll past this one (no hard feelings!). But if you're interested in seeing how intentional planning can potentially double your retirement wealth... stick with me.

Because what I'm about to show you will change everything you think you know about retirement success.

While Everyone Else Is Playing the Accumulation Game, Smart Retirees Are Playing Strategy

Here's what drives me crazy about traditional retirement planning.

Most people - and most advisors - are obsessed with one thing: growing the pile of money as big as possible. They'll debate whether to put 60% or 70% in stocks. They'll argue about international diversification. They'll chase the latest hot investment.

But they're missing the most important question: What's your plan for turning that pile into reliable income?

It's like spending years perfecting your recipe but never learning how to cook. You might have all the right ingredients, but without the right process, you're still going to end up hungry.

The same principle applies to retirement planning.


The Three Retirement Approaches (And Their Shocking Results)

Let me show you exactly what I mean with real numbers.

I'm going to use a simple scenario: $1 million starting balance, need $50,000 annual income. Here are the three most common approaches people take:

Approach 1: All-Equity Strategy

"Nothing has outperformed the S&P 500 over the long term. I'll put everything in stock indexes and withdraw what I need."

Approach 2: Traditional 60/40 Portfolio

"I'll take some risk off the table with a balanced approach - 60% stocks, 40% bonds."

Approach 3: Intentional Planning

"I'll get laser-focused on creating guaranteed income first, then optimize growth with what's left."

Now, here's where it gets interesting. I ran these three strategies using actual market returns over the last 25 years. Not hypothetical returns - real data from 2000 to 2024.

The results will shock you.


The Results That Change Everything

All-Equity Strategy Result: If you had started with $1 million in 2000 and withdrawn $50,000 annually using pure equity investments, you would have run out of money around 2014.

That's right - you wouldn't have made it through a 25-year retirement. The sequence of returns would have killed your portfolio during the bad decades.

Traditional 60/40 Strategy Result: Starting with $1 million in 2000, withdrawing $50,000 annually with a 60/40 split, you'd have $1 million left today.

Your advisor would be shaking your hand saying, "Great job! We lived 25 years and didn't touch the principal!" You might feel happy with that result.

But I think you deserve more. In fact, I know you deserve more.

Intentional Planning Result: Here's where it gets really interesting. With intentional planning, I took $675,000 and got laser-focused on creating guaranteed income. This ensures the $50,000 annual income regardless of market conditions.

The remaining $325,000? Pure growth investments. No withdrawals. No interruptions. Just compound growth for 25 years.

The result: Nearly $2 million.

Let me repeat that: $2 million versus $1 million using the same starting balance and the same market conditions.


Why Intentional Planning Destroys Traditional Approaches

The difference comes down to one critical principle: uninterrupted compound growth.

When you have a traditional portfolio, you're constantly taking money out. Sometimes you're selling when markets are up. Sometimes when they're down. You're interrupting the growth process and likely selling things you shouldn't touch.

It's like trying to grow a garden while constantly digging up the plants to check the roots.

With intentional planning, you solve the income problem first. Once that's handled, your growth money can compound without interruption for decades.

The math is undeniable:

  • All-equity: Ran out of money

  • 60/40: $1 million (broke even)

  • Intentional: $2 million (doubled your money)


The Behavior Problem Nobody Talks About

Here's what really gets me fired up about this: Traditional portfolios have no intention.

They just "weeble and wobble through the ocean" while you constantly take money out and put pressure on them. You're cashing out positions whether they're up, down, or sideways.

Your behavior is holding your money down.

When you get intentional and separate income from growth, something magical happens:

  • Your income is guaranteed regardless of market conditions

  • Your growth money compounds without interference

  • You sleep better knowing your lifestyle is protected

  • Your wealth actually grows faster with less stress

It's the difference between playing defense and offense simultaneously.


The Return on Life vs. Return on Money

Here's something most financial advisors will never tell you: The return on your life often matters more than the return on your money.

What good is an extra 1% annual return if you're constantly stressed about market volatility? What's the point of a perfectly optimized portfolio if you can't sleep at night during market downturns?

Intentional planning gives you both better returns AND better peace of mind.

When your income is guaranteed, you can actually enjoy retirement instead of constantly worrying about your portfolio balance. You can take that trip to Europe without checking your 401(k) balance every morning.

That's what intentional planning gets you.


But Here's What Really Matters

These aren't hypothetical numbers or backtested theories. This is what actually happened over the last 25 years using real market data.

The next 25 years will be different. There will be ups and downs we can't predict. But the principle remains the same: intentional planning consistently outperforms traditional approaches.

Why? Because it's based on controlling what you can control (your income strategy) rather than hoping for what you can't control (market performance).


The Opportunity Cost That's Killing Me

Here's what keeps me up at night: Every day, people retire using traditional approaches that leave massive amounts of money on the table.

They're worried about asset allocation percentages while missing the fundamental strategy that could double their retirement wealth.

It's like debating the color of your car while ignoring the fact that you're driving in the wrong direction.

The families who understand intentional planning aren't just retiring comfortably - they're building generational wealth while enjoying stress-free retirements.


Your Move

Look, I'm not saying everyone should abandon diversification and throw caution to the wind. Intentional planning requires careful analysis of your specific situation and goals.

But I am saying you should understand what's possible.

If you're approaching retirement with substantial assets and want to see how intentional planning might work in your situation, the numbers might surprise you.

The question is: Are you going to keep following the same accumulation-focused playbook as everyone else? Or are you going to get intentional about creating the retirement you actually want?

If you want to see what this might look like in your specific situation...

I'm offering a limited number of 1-on-1 Possibility Planning sessions for people who are serious about getting intentional with their retirement strategy. It's not for everyone - I'm looking for people with substantial assets who are ready to think beyond traditional approaches.

During your private session with me, we'll analyze your specific situation, design an intentional income strategy, and show you exactly how this approach could impact your retirement wealth and peace of mind.

Click here to schedule your 1-on-1 Possibility Planning session →

Because the best retirement isn't about having the most money. It's about having the most intentional plan.

And the numbers prove it works.

Book Your Possibility Plan

As a CPA and financial advisor, I’ve helped thousands of people ‘Retire Well’. Retirement should be the time when you can finally relax and enjoy yourself.

Andrew Hall

As a CPA and financial advisor, I’ve helped thousands of people ‘Retire Well’. Retirement should be the time when you can finally relax and enjoy yourself.

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog

Keep Reading

Retire Well Report

Access the free report that reveals how to enjoy retirement sooner without taking a pay cut.

Online Webinar

Learn how you can enjoy financial freedom, safeguard wealth, and ensure a lasting legacy for your family.

Book A No-Cost Possibility Session

Schedule No-Cost 1-on-1 Possibility Planning Session. Spaces are limited due to availability.

Copyright © 2024 All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy - Cookie Disclaimer - Terms & Conditions

Virtus Wealth Management LLC ("Virtus Wealth"), dba Virtus Financial Group, is a Registered Investment Advisor ("RIA"), located in the State of Missouri. Virtus Wealth provides investment advisory and related services for clients nationally. Virtus Wealth will maintain all applicable registration and licenses as required by the various states in which Virtus Wealth conducts business, as applicable. Virtus Wealth renders individualized responses to persons in a particular state only after complying with all regulatory requirements, or pursuant to an applicable state exemption or exclusion

The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal or investment advice and it should not be relied on as such. It should not be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security. It does not take into account any investor's particular investment objectives, strategies, tax status or investment horizon. You should consult your attorney or tax advisor.


Virtus Wealth Management LLC has been listed on the Better Business Bureau website since November 2022. The grade given to Virtus Wealth Management LLC is based on several factors including customer reviews, customer complaints, and time in business, among others. Compensation has been provided to the Better Business Bureau to be graded and listed on their website.